First screen, captured 3 days ago. Hover to scroll the page, or open the video.

AI isn't replacing SREs, it's deskilling them

What HN thinks

Half the thread is arguing about airline pilots, the other half is cancelling Proton subscriptions, and Claude is quietly reading the logs.

Learn from aviation's practice mandates
Many like the idea of mandated manual practice, like pilots' required hand-flying hours, though others note it only works because the FAA forces it and companies have no such incentive.
Skill atrophy is real
Spotting AI mistakes requires the hands-on knowledge that AI now does for you, so engineers who outsource understanding lose the ability to supervise it.
AI troubleshooting is genuinely superior
Some report agents root-causing outages and CI failures far faster than humans, and argue the atrophying skills are simply no longer needed.

Consensus: Most agree AI is very useful for incident work but that someone still needs real system understanding to verify it, and that without regulation or incentives companies won't pay to keep that skill alive.

Recommended in the comments

Elixir (tool): Recommended for reliable web projects with cheap high availability and good agent-written code.
Fastmail (service): Suggested as a Proton alternative after the CEO's security remarks.
mailbox.org (service): Suggested as a European, IMAP-capable Proton alternative.
How Complex Systems Fail ↗ (book): Cited as the textbook framing of aviation-style complex system safety.

Summarised by Claude from the comment thread 2 days ago.

Points: 579
Comments: 425
Best rank: #1
Posted: 2026-10-30 by dorianniemiec
Category: Devops infra

sre deskilling incident-response ironies-of-automation observability signoz ai-automation

All captures:

Full page

Captured 3 days ago. Click for the whole screenshot.

Looks similar

Screenshot of sunshowers.io: Debugging a rustc segfault on Illumos

Debugging a rustc segfault on Illumos (sunshowers.io)

217 points by steveklabnik 2 years ago | 56 comments

Screenshot of kellyshortridge.com: Cybersecurity Isn't Special

Cybersecurity Isn't Special (kellyshortridge.com)

30 points by todsacerdoti 2 years ago | 37 comments

Screenshot of divagr.com: Qwenputer: A functioning, deterministic RISC-V CPU inside Qwen3.5

Qwenputer: A functioning, deterministic RISC-V CPU inside Qwen3.5 (divagr.com)

666 points by csmantle 4 days ago | 140 comments

Blog post describing Qwenputer, a Qwen3.5 4B model with a RISC-V CPU compiled into its weights that uses Gated DeltaNet layers as RAM to run code internally.

qwen risc-v gated-deltanet compiled-weights