First screen, captured 5 hours ago. Hover to scroll the page, or open the video.

Why are Soviet math textbooks so hardcore in comparison to US textbooks? (2017)

What HN thinks

A thread that started with textbooks and ended, as all education threads must, at school boards, Sputnik and who invented Silicon Valley.

Soviets sifted, didn't polish
The hard books reflect a system that didn't care if many students fell behind; it aimed to find and push talented kids via elite schools, olympiads and math circles.
Western schools dumbed math down
Many argue US (and some Western) curricula lowered standards and removed advanced tracks, citing California algebra debates, NJ oversight and weak college readiness.
Survivorship bias and nuance
Westerners mostly meet the best emigrants; average Soviet schools had cheating and bribery, and US textbooks are arguably better for self-study while innovation still flourished in the West.

Consensus: Most agree the Soviet system was more demanding and selective, but there is no consensus on whether it produced better outcomes overall.

Recommended in the comments

Math circles ↗ (other): Cited as a key part of the Eastern bloc approach to developing talented students.
Differential and Integral Calculus (book): Remembered as covering far more than typical university courses.
Calculus (book): Praised as difficult but great to learn from.
Russian School of Math (service): Introduces variables early, which a commenter considered a great way to teach.

Summarised by Claude from the comment thread 3 hours ago.

Points: 126
Comments: 169
Best rank: #5
Posted: 2026-11-02 by zenincognito
Category: Education

mathematics-education soviet-textbooks textbooks quora physics-education

Capture showed: Error page

All captures:

Full page

Captured 5 hours ago. Click for the whole screenshot.

Looks similar

Screenshot of reddit.com: R/open source bans all solo projects and projects using LLMs

R/open source bans all solo projects and projects using LLMs (reddit.com)

38 points by schleck8 8 days ago | 12 comments

Reddit r/opensource post about banning solo projects and LLM-built projects; the page shows a Reddit network-security block requiring login.

reddit r-opensource llm ai-generated-code

Screenshot of reddit.com: Lenovo's 'encrypted' fingerprint USB is just an unencrypted SD card in a case

Lenovo's 'encrypted' fingerprint USB is just an unencrypted SD card in a case (reddit.com)

522 points by entryleveljobsc 1 day ago | 168 comments

Reddit r/technology post about a Lenovo fingerprint 'encrypted' USB drive found to be an unencrypted SD card; the page shows a network-security block.

lenovo encryption usb-drives fingerprint-authentication

Screenshot of reddit.com: Frontier Airlines Likely Breached

Frontier Airlines Likely Breached (reddit.com)

180 points by 999900000999 1 day ago | 75 comments

Reddit thread in r/frontierairlines warning about a scam email, suggesting a possible Frontier Airlines data breach; the page shown is a Reddit network-security block.

frontier-airlines data-breach phishing email-scam

Screenshot of twitter.com: Root shell on Samsung TV

Root shell on Samsung TV (twitter.com)

830 points by testing22321 9 days ago | 617 comments

Reddit post in r/antiai about a hacker reverse engineering a Samsung TV and finding on-board AI listening; page shows a Reddit network-security block.

samsung smart-tv reverse-engineering privacy

Screenshot of reddit.com: Archive.today links going forward

Archive.today links going forward (reddit.com)

190 points by consumer451 5 days ago | 134 comments

A Reddit r/Seattle post about archive.today links going forward after mods reportedly found malware injection; the page shows a Reddit network security block.

archive-today malware reddit content-moderation