Impressive but heavily pre-trained
Many argue the model has absorbed every wiki, guide and blueprint, and peaceful mode removes real-time pressure, so this is far from learning a game from scratch.
It skipped the core mechanic
Commenters note Sol hand-fed chests instead of belt routing, treating the player as a logistics unit; humans would find that tedious and it doesn't scale.
LLMs in games as features
A large tangent wants small LLMs enriching NPC dialogue, diplomacy and strategy opponents, with debate over whether AI-written dialogue ruins the art.