Pure nostalgia, works shockingly well
Many were amazed it runs smoothly on phones and tablets, with chaotic multiplayer free roam and the iconic soundtrack bringing back childhood memories.
Illegal, and donations make it worse
Several note the site redistributes copyrighted assets and licensed music, and soliciting donations invites a takedown from EA or music rights holders.
Copyright should allow abandonware preservation
Others argue that when publishers stop selling games, preservation and non-commercial redistribution should be permitted, with proposals for shorter terms or abandonment rules.